Daniel H. McCullough papers

 Collection
Identifier: MS-0603

Collection Organization

The McCullough Papers are the personal papers, photographs, scrapbooks and publications of prominent Toledo defense lawyer, Dan McCullough (1898-1976). Thirty-seven scrapbooks are the main series of this collection. They contain newsclippings and memorabilia dating from 1932 to 1974 covering cases handled by McCullough as well as his involvement in Toledo's high society. His cases included numerous gambling and pinball cases in the 1930s and 1940s and civil liberty/due process cases in the 1950s and 1960s. One of his most interesting and infamous cases was the defense of Rose La Rose, owner of a well-known Toledo burlesque showplace. The scrapbooks also detail McCullough's participation in social events in Toledo; theater, opera and especially polo.

Two other series form an important part of the collection. The first is an extensive series of photographs. Unfortunately, most are not identified nor dated and thus grouped only by subject. The other series is a collection of McCullough's speeches and articles responding to the civil liberties movement of the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, of which he was a tireless and prominent supporter.

The collection does not include any complete case files and is frustratingly silent on the extent of his work in the civil liberties movement. It will, however, serve as an excellent starting point for researchers investigating the Toledo law community and national and local legal issues during the time period 1930 to 1970, and for those working specifically on the life of Dan McCullough.

Biographical

 Series

BIOGRAPHICAL MATERIAL; one folder; no arrangement, scattered dates. Contains newsclippings, official records and miscellaneous information on the life of Dan McCullough.

GENEALOGICAL MATERIAL; one folder; no arrangement. Family tree information compiled by Dan McCullough.

Biographical Material, undated

 File – Box 1, Folder: 1
Dates
Creation: undated

Genealogical Material, undated

 File – Box 1, Folder: 2
Dates
Creation: undated

Scrapbooks and scrapbook material, 1932-1974

 Series

SCRAPBOOKS-PERSONAL; 26 volumes, numbered; 1932-1964; arranged chronologically. Collections of newsclippings and memorabilia involving McCullough's cases and his participation in Toledo society. Numbered 1-14, 16, 17, 18 1/2, 21-28, 32.

SCRAPBOOKS-PERSONAL; 11 volumes, unnumbered; 1946-1974; arranged chronologically. Collections of newsclippings and memorabilia involving McCullough's cases and his participation in Toledo society.

Dates
Creation: 1932-1974

#1 Todak Case, Emmert Fraud Case, Bonus March, 1932-1933

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1932-1933

#2 Vacchiano/Bruno Murder Cases, Kennedy Murder Trial, 1933-1934

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1933-1934

Folder of evidence from Vacchiano Trial, 1933

 File – Box 2, Folder: 1
Dates
Creation: 1933

#3 "Butch" the Dog Trial, Slot Machine Wars, Aronoff/Gambling, 1934-1936

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1934-1936

#4 Aronoff/Gambling, Dog Racing, 1936-1937

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 4
Dates
Creation: 1936-1937

#5 Bolinger Bribery Trial, Gambling, 1937-1939

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 5
Dates
Creation: 1937-1939

#6 Gambling, 1939-1941

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 6
Dates
Creation: 1939-1941

#7 Gambling, Obituaries of Prominent Toledoans, 1941-1942

 Item – Box 2, Volume: 7
Dates
Creation: 1941-1942

#8 Gambling, Obituaries of Prominent Toledoans, 1943-1946

 Item – Box 3, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1943-1946

#9 Aronoff/Gambling, 1944-1945

 Item – Box 3, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1944-1945

#10 Steeplechase, Horse Shows, 1945-1946

 Item – Box 3, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1945-1946

#11 Music Publisher Raid, Urbaytis Murder, 1946-1947

 Item – Box 3, Volume: 4
Dates
Creation: 1946-1947

#12 Toledo (from Saturday Evening Post), Gambling, 1948

 Item – Box 3, Volume: 5
Dates
Creation: 1948

#13 Obituaries of Prominent Toledoans, Remington Murder Case, Gambling, Hit-Skip Case, 1948-1950

 Item – Box 3, Volume: 6
Dates
Creation: 1948-1950

#14 Verderber Case, Air Pollution, Stranahan Paternity Suit, Contraceptives Case, 1951-1954

 Item – Box 4, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1951-1954

#16 Gambling, Juke Box "Racket", Anti-Pinball Machine Movement, 1949-1956

 Item – Box 4, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1949-1956

#17 Civil Liberties,Schreiber Trial, 1954-1957

 Item – Box 4, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1954-1957

#18 1/2 Pinball Ban, 1956-1959

 Item – Box 4, Volume: 4
Dates
Creation: 1956-1959

#21 Local Social Events, Stratford Festival, 1958

 Item – Box 4, Volume: 5
Dates
Creation: 1958

#22 Social Events (Dodges, Bentleys, Stranahans), Foreign Travel, 1958-1959

 Item – Box 4, Volume: 6
Dates
Creation: 1958-1959

#23 Springbrook Polo Club, Social Events, Stratford, 1959

 Item – Box 5, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1959

#24 Social Events, 1959-1960

 Item – Box 5, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1959-1960

#25 Social Events, Polo, 1960

 Item – Box 5, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1960

#26 Social Events, Kennedy Inaugural, 1960-1961

 Item – Box 5, Volume: 4
Dates
Creation: 1960-1961

#27 Social Events, Polo, 1961

 Item – Box 6, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1961

#28 Social Events, Polo, 1961-1962

 Item – Box 6, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1961-1962

#32 Social Events, 1964

 Item – Box 6, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1964

Polo, Horse Shows, Fox Hunts, 1946-1952

 Item – Box 7, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1946-1952

Polo, 1949-1958

 Item – Box 7, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1949-1958

Polo, 1950-1960

 Item – Box 7, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1950-1960

Polo, 1951, 1958-1961

 Item – Box 7, Volume: 4
Dates
Creation: 1951, 1958-1961

Canterbury Pilgrimage from Dorset Farm, 1959

 Item – Box 8, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1959

Court Cases, Deportation of Findlay Professor, Findlay College Student Court Case, "Due Process", Dispute with Toledo Edison, Driscoll-Blade Libel Suit, 1959-1967

 Item – Box 8, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1959-1967

Social Events, Polo, 1960-1962

 Item – Box 9, Volume: 1
Dates
Creation: 1960-1962

Bail Bond Conference, 1964-1965

 Item – Box 9, Volume: 2
Dates
Creation: 1964-1965

"Torture" Case, Abortion Case, Drug Cases, 1967-1968

 Item – Box 9, Volume: 3
Dates
Creation: 1967-1968

Rose La Rose Cases, 1968-1972

 Item – Box 9, Volume: 4
Dates
Creation: 1968-1972

Ottawa County Sheriff Perjury Trial, Drug Cases, Stranahan Divorce, 1970-1974

 Item – Box 9, Volume: 5
Dates
Creation: 1970-1974

Publications, 1899, 1954-1975

 Series

PUBLICATIONS; two folders; 1899, 1961;. arranged alphabetically. McCullough's personal copy of the Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam and a masters thesis.

PERSONAL SPEECHES/ARTICLES; nine folders; 1954-1975; arranged alphabetically. Various speeches and law articles concerning civil liberties.

Dates
Creation: 1899, 1954-1975

Bail Bond Conference (c.2), 1964-1965

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 1
Dates
Creation: 1964-1965

The Killits-Cochran Controversy (masters thesis), Jena Kohl, University of Toledo, 1961

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 2
Dates
Creation: 1961

Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam (personal copy--contains list of places stationed during WWI), 1899

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 3
Dates
Creation: 1899

"Balancing the Rights of the Accused and the Public In Constitutional Probity," reprint from ABA Journal, Volume 54, March 1968

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 4
Dates
Creation: March 1968

"The Press and the First Amendment", May 1954

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 5
Dates
Creation: May 1954

"Right of Discovery in Criminal Cases, or the Lack Thereof Under Ohio Law," reprint from Ohio Opinions, July 29 1968

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 6
Dates
Creation: July 29 1968

"Right-to-work Amendment", October 1958

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 7
Dates
Creation: October 1958

"The Sunset of the Criminal Lawyer," ABA Journal, Volume 50, March 1964

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 8
Dates
Creation: March 1964

"Trial by Newspaper-Free Press and Fair Trial," South Dakota Law Review, Volume 12, Number 1, Winter 1967

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 9
Dates
Creation: Winter 1967

"Trial by Newspaper-Free Press and Fair Trial, (Part Two)", South Dakota Law Review, Volume 12, Number 2, Spring 1967

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 10
Dates
Creation: Spring 1967

"Trial Techniques in the Defence of a Criminal Prosecution", 1962

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 11
Dates
Creation: 1962

"Why the Exclusionary Rule Should be Retained," reprint from Ohio Bar, Volume 48, Number 24, June 16, 1975

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 12
Dates
Creation: June 16, 1975

Audio/Visual, 1890-1970s

 Series

PHOTOGRAPHS; 32 folders/scrapbooks; 1890-1970s; partially arranged chronologically and by subject. Photographs of McCullough, family and friends. Includes photographs from WWI and postcards.

TAPE RECORDINGS-CITY COUNCIL; four tapes; March 18, 1968. Tapes in various formats of McCullough's defense of Rose La Rose before Toledo City Council.

TAPE RECORDINGS-CRIMINAL INSANITY INSTITUTE; one tape, reel to reel; April 1962. Tape of McCullough's speech at the Institute.

Dates
Creation: 1890-1970s

Family, 1890-1920s

 File – Box 10, Folder: 13
Dates
Creation: 1890-1920s

Family, 1930s-1960s

 File – Box 10, Folder: 14
Dates
Creation: 1930s-1960s

Family/Friends, 1970s

 File – Box 10, Folder: 15
Dates
Creation: 1970s

Dan with Family, 1940s

 File – Box 10, Folder: 16
Dates
Creation: 1940s

Family Portraits, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 17
Dates
Creation: undated

Family-Partial photo album, undated

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 18
Dates
Creation: undated

Family-Dan, mother and brother (?), undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 19
Dates
Creation: undated

Family - Dan and Brother (?), undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 20
Dates
Creation: undated

Family - WWII Photographs, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 21
Dates
Creation: undated

Funeral, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 22
Dates
Creation: undated

Photo Scrapbook with other miscellaneous items, undated

 Item – Box 10, Folder: 23
Dates
Creation: undated

Dan's 85 feet dive, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 24
Dates
Creation: undated

Unidentified photographs, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 25
Dates
Creation: undated

Friends/Snapshots of Dan (2 folders), undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 26
Dates
Creation: undated

Social Functions, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 27
Dates
Creation: undated

Unidentified friends, undated

 File – Box 10, Folder: 28
Dates
Creation: undated

First Communion (oversized-located in Box 7), 1911/1935

 File – Box 10, Folder: 29
Dates
Creation: 1911/1935

Dan in office, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 1
Dates
Creation: undated

Office photographs, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 2
Dates
Creation: undated

Dan at work, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 3
Dates
Creation: undated

Dan and cars, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 4
Dates
Creation: undated

Polo and horse riding, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 5
Dates
Creation: undated

Places, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 6
Dates
Creation: undated

Dan and Lyndon B. Johnson, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 7
Dates
Creation: undated

Group photo - School?, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 8
Dates
Creation: undated

WWI photographs, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 9
Dates
Creation: undated

Post cards and Christmas cards, undated

 File – Box 11, Folder: 11
Dates
Creation: undated

McCullough before City Council, re: Rose La Rose (2 cassette tapes and 2 reel-to-reel tapes-1/4"), March 18, 1968

 Item – Box 12, Folder: 1
Dates
Creation: March 18, 1968

McCullough-Criminal Insanity Institute (1 reel-to-reel tape -1/4"), April 1962

 Item – Box 12, Folder: 2
Dates
Creation: April 1962

Artifact, 1963

 Series

PLAQUE; 1963. Opinion page of The Blade concerning McCullough-Edison "war".

Dates
Creation: 1963

Plaque: Opinion Page of The Blade re: McCullough and Edison War, undated

 Item – Box 12, Folder: 1
Dates
Creation: undated